Insights

/

Choosing the Best Amazon Agency: Red Flags, Models and a Scorecard

Cash & Profit

Choosing the Best Amazon Agency: Red Flags, Models and a Scorecard

Written openly by an operator-run Amazon agency: red flags and the questions to ask, PPC-only vs full-service vs aggregator, and a scorecard for finalists.

The Evolved Commerce Editorial Team

·

Content @ Evolved Commerce

·

·

19 min read

var(--variable-Qxxbx0ZzH)

TOPICS COVERED

Options for selecting partners for Amazon

TOPICS COVERED

Options for selecting partners for Amazon

TALK TO US

Article making sense?

If anything from what we wrote here resonates with you and what you are going through, let's chat.

Talk to an operator

We won't rank anyone here. Not ourselves, not anyone else. Most “best agency” lists are written by agencies. You already know who comes first on those. You get the tools instead:

  1. A red-flag table, with the question to ask and what a straight answer sounds like.

  2. A map of who owns each part of the channel under PPC-only and full-service.

  3. A plain comparison of agency, reseller and aggregator.

  4. A scorecard for your finalists.

  5. One lean founder's month, and who catches the stockout.

Our perspective put simply: Our philosophy is that a a founder with no Amazon team should hire an operator-run, full-service partner. Paid on sales, never on ad spend. Account in your name. Reporting on margin and TACOS, not only ROAS. We say why below, and where that advice is wrong for you.

Amazon is a relevancy engine. There are no tricks. Any agency worth hiring will tell you the same.


A checklist infographic titled Agency Scorecard: What to Check, listing three must-haves (pay tied to your sales, account in your name, a named lead who does the work) and two strong signals (full scope in the contract, margin and TACOS reporting).

What are the red flags when evaluating Amazon agencies?

The first red flag is an agency that asks for your password or builds the account using it's own profile. Next, check how it is paid, what it promises and who does the work. Each flag below comes with the question to ask during your evaluation process and what a straight answer sounds like.

An agency should never need your password. Amazon says so itself. Its seller guidance reads: “Do not share your password; use User Permissions to provide access instead.” Outside providers should be added as Authorized Partners, not Secondary Users. And you can cut off any app connected to your account whenever you choose.

Fake reviews have grown into a legal problem, not just a policy one. The Federal Trade Commission's final rule bans buying or selling them. It lets the any party impacted seek civil penalties against anyone who breaks it knowingly. Amazon has also sued review brokers. It's typical to see offers for promised “100% safe” reviews that would lift rankings and sales. If an agency pitches anything like that, this should raise a major red flag for you to consider their services.

Red flag

Ask on the call

A credible answer sounds like

Asks for your primary login

“How will you get into the account?”

“Add us as an Authorized Partner in User Permissions. We never need your password.”

Builds the account or campaigns in their account and keeps the history

“Whose name is on the account and the campaigns? What stays with me if we part?”

“Everything is built in your account. It stays yours.”

Paid a cut of ad spend

“What do you earn when spend goes up and sales don't?”

“Nothing extra. Our fee isn't tied to your spend.”

A retainer with no stake in results

“What happens to your fee if sales fall?”

“Part of it falls too. We're paid on what you sell.”

A percentage of sales with no margin reporting

“Could your fee tempt you to buy sales at a loss?”

“It could. So we report margin and TACOS, and you can check them.”

Promises reviews or guaranteed rankings

“How will you get reviews and rank?”

“No guarantees. Rank follows sales and conversion. Reviews come from real buyers.”

Reports only ACoS or ROAS

“What will I see, and how often?”

“TACOS and margin next to ROAS, on a set schedule.”

Won't name who runs the account weekly

“Who works in my account each week? Are they on this call?”

“Here's the person. Yes, they're here.”

Promises results faster than an honest rebuild

“When do you expect break-even, and why?”

“A range, with reasons. Months, not weeks.”

Never says when you are not a fit

“Who do you turn away?”

“Here's who, and here's why. Maybe you.”

An ad spend recap for you just in case you need a refresher: ROAS is ad sales divided by ad spend. ACoS is the reverse: ad spend divided by ad sales. TACOS is ad spend divided by total sales, paid and organic. Only TACOS shows whether ads lift the whole account. None of the three is profit.

Every fee model has a weak spot. Treat them evenly.

  • A cut of ad spend pays the agency more when you spend more, whether sales follow or not.

  • A flat retainer pays the same when you grow and when you shrink.

  • A percentage of sales can tempt an agency to buy volume at your margin's expense.

We charge a flat retainer plus 3% of attributed sales. Never a cut of your ad spend. The fair question back: could that 3% tempt us to chase volume? It could. That is why we report margin and TACOS, not only ROAS. Ask any provider on a sales-based fee to show you the same.

If your current agency shows any of these behaviors

Don't tear it down in a day. Run some due diligence and check the following:

  1. Open User Permissions in Seller Central. See who has access.

  2. Check if they are an Authorized Partner directly from the Amazon Partner Directory

  3. Revoke connected apps you no longer want on the account.

  4. Ask in writing which campaigns, listings and data sit in your account and which sit in theirs. History built outside your account may not come with you. Find out now.

  5. Ask for recent margin and TACOS figures. If they can't produce them, that's your answer.

With us, the account stays in your name. You keep the account, the brand and the relationship with Amazon. Your data is never sold or shared with third parties. You can revoke our access at any time.

What is the difference between a full-service Amazon agency and a PPC-only agency?

A PPC-only agency runs your ads. A full-service team runs the whole channel: ads, listings and content, inventory planning, account health, promotions and reporting. The gap matters because ads depend on the other five. When nobody owns them, they land on your desk. You become the go-between.

Ads stop when the inventory runs out. Ad software vendors list why an enabled campaign stops delivering. The product is out of stock, suppressed, or has lost the Buy Box. Another vendor puts it flatly: an ad only shows when its product is in stock and holds the Featured Offer. The Featured Offer is the new name for the Buy Box. It is the offer Amazon puts first on the product page.

So ad results depend on work outside the ads.

Here's a breakdown of each area of Amazon that has to be managed:

Parts of Amazon to Manage

PPC-only agency

Full-service team

What lands on you when nobody owns it

Advertising

Agency

Team

Covered in both.

Listings and content

You

Team

Ads send clicks to a page that doesn't convert. Ad and listing keywords drift apart.

Inventory planning

You

Team

A stockout. Ads stop serving. Sales slow, and organic rank with them.

Account health

You

Team

Warnings sit unread. A suppressed listing quietly stops its ads.

Promotions

You

Team

Deals clash with ad budgets, or never run.

Reporting

Agency, ads only

Team, whole channel

You see ROAS. You don't see what you kept.

The hidden cost is being the middle. The ads agency spots a problem. You chase the fix. You report back. Every week.

PPC-only isn't wrong. It works when someone in-house owns the other five areas. If you have that person, hire for ads and keep the rest.

Watch the label, though. “Full-service” means different things at different agencies. Amazon itself lists account management as its own service type, apart from advertising. It describes hands-on help with day-to-day operations, listing optimization and growth strategy. Define full-service by tasks, not by the name. Get all six areas written into the scope.

Here is ours, as one example: Our full-service management covers all six areas under one retainer. A dedicated growth expert handles strategy, pricing and packaging, account maintenance and channel growth. The same team runs your ads and listings on one keyword set. Our PPC-only service includes inventory-aware bidding and TACOS reporting. Full account management is an add-on there.

On one account, we've built 87 secondary images, 20 Premium A+ modules, 37 storefronts and a Brand Story. That was across five years on the retainer. The count is from our own results page. You can see how the six areas run under one retainer, with the account kept in your name.

What is the difference between an Amazon agency and an aggregator?

An agency runs your account for a fee. You keep the brand, the account and the stock. A reseller, or distribution partner, buys your inventory wholesale and sells it. You still keep the brand. An aggregator buys the brand itself. You get paid once you sell the brand and step away. Three different deals, often pitched in similar words.

The reseller model is simple. One large public company in this space buys wholesale inventory from brands and resells it online. That is its core model, as one trade report described it. When exclusivity ends, the brand can sell on Amazon itself or move to another reseller.

An aggregator deal works differently. You usually get a lump sum when the deal closes. You might get more later, depending on how the brand performs after the sale. That later money is an earnout. It depends on people you no longer control.


Agency

Reseller or distribution partner

Aggregator

Who owns the brand

You

You

The aggregator, after the sale

Whose Seller Central account

Yours

The reseller's, as the authorized seller

The aggregator's

Who buys and holds inventory

You

The reseller, at wholesale

The aggregator

How the partner is paid

A fee from you

The gap between wholesale and retail

It pays you: a lump sum, maybe more later

Who captures the upside

You, less the fee

Shared: you sell the units, the reseller keeps the retail margin

The aggregator, apart from any earnout

What exit looks like

End the contract on its terms

When exclusivity ends, sell it yourself or through another reseller

You've sold the brand. There's no way back.

An honest note on how the aggregator wave played out. Aggregators raised large sums to roll up independent Amazon sellers. It didn't go to plan. Thrasio, the best-known of them, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in early 2024, as CNBC reported. Many aggregators bought brands they failed to grow. Some failed even to hold existing sales. Today, practically none are still growing by buying brands.

Selling isn't always wrong. If you want out, and cash now matters more than upside, it can fit. Just treat the earnout as uncertain money.

Not sure which deal is on the table? Ask three questions:

  1. Who owns the brand after we sign?

  2. Whose account will the product sell from?

  3. Who pays for the next order of stock?

Where we sit. We offer two models. As an agency, we run your account on retainer. You keep the inventory. The account stays in your name. We're paid a flat retainer plus 3% of attributed sales. In distribution, we buy the units outright, own the ad spend and carry the returns. You keep your capital, and you keep the brand. We don't buy brands.

What should I look for in an Amazon agency?

Look for three must-haves first: pay tied to your sales, not your spend; the account in your name; and a named lead who does the work. Then score the strong signals: scope, cadence, reporting you can see, category experience, and honesty about fit and timing. Use one sheet for every finalist.

A directory listing is a floor, not a verdict. Amazon's service provider network says it lists providers “solely as an informational resource.” It does not endorse any of them. If you hire one, you contract with them directly. They work at your direction. So the contract is what you're really vetting.

Use a chart like this one to detail and identify if the potential partners you are selecting meet the necessary criteria:

Criterion

Why it matters

Proof to ask for

Finalist A

Finalist B

Finalist C

Must-have: incentive alignment

They should earn more only when you sell more

The fee clause, in writing




Must-have: account in your name

Your history and control stay with you

Access as an Authorized Partner; ownership in the contract




Must-have: a named lead who does the work

The junior handoff happens after the sale

The person's name and role, and a meeting before you sign




Strong signal: scope across all six areas

Ads fail when stock, listings or health break

All six named in the contract, plus what's excluded




Strong signal: cadence, and who acts on low stock

A stockout costs rank as well as sales

The meeting schedule, and who owns reorder alerts




Strong signal: reporting you can see any time

A monthly deck shows what someone chose to show

A dashboard you can open yourself, with margin and TACOS




Strong signal: category experience

Categories differ in ad cost and season

Named brands near your category, with numbers and dates




Strong signal: honest fit and timeline

Fast promises are a sales tactic

Their break-even range, and who they turn away




Mark each box your way and notate as needed. If a finalist misses a must-have, stop there.

Here is how we'd fill in our own row. Check it against the others.

  • Fee: a flat retainer plus 3% of attributed sales. Never a cut of ad spend.

  • Lead: a dedicated growth expert.

  • Cadence: bi-weekly meetings on performance and strategy, and bi-weekly reporting.

  • Visibility: a complimentary business intelligence dashboard for every client.

  • Reporting: margin and TACOS, not only ROAS.

  • Proof: on Pro Lash, after the 2025 rebuild, TACOS fell from 21.5% to 15.1%. ROAS rose from 2.7 to 3.8. Both figures are from our Pro Lash case study.

You can see how our paid-on-sales model and scope are set out.

On badges. We hold Amazon Ads verified partner status, based on data from the Amazon Ads Partner Network. It's a data point in choosing a partner. It isn't a guarantee of results, and we won't sell it as one. Here is what our partner status does and doesn't mean, and how to check our listing in Amazon's public partner directory.

Amazon, Amazon Ads, and all related logos are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc., or its affiliates.

Which kind of Amazon agency fits a founder-led brand without an in-house team?

If nobody in-house runs Amazon, a full-service team with one dedicated lead usually fits best. It is the one model where a single person watches ads, stock and account health together. You still make the money calls. You stop being the go-between, and you stop finding problems by accident.

You run Seller Central around everything else. Product, wholesale, hiring, cash. You're not unusual. In a seller survey from December 2020, 70% of Amazon sellers had other work outside their Amazon business. It's older data. The picture is still familiar.

Here is one month, three ways. Your best seller runs low in week two. A listing is suppressed in week three. An account-health warning lands in week four.

In the month

PPC-only agency

A set of freelancers

Full-service team, one lead

Stock runs low

May see ads stop. The reorder is yours.

Nobody owns the reorder plan. You find out late.

The lead watches stock against the ad plan and flags the reorder early.

A listing is suppressed

Outside scope. Its ads quietly stop.

The listing freelancer fixes it once you notice and ask.

The lead spots it, fixes it and resets the ads.

Account-health warning

Lands in your inbox.

Lands in your inbox.

The lead reads it, acts and tells you.

Who coordinates fixes

You

You

The lead

What you still decide

Everything outside the ads

Everything between the freelancers

Inventory purchases and cash calls. You approve; the lead runs it.

Why this matters. An ad stops serving when its product is out of stock, suppressed or off the Featured Offer. No alarm goes off. The spend just stops working.

You'll read that you need a certain revenue before full-service pays. Revenue does decide whether a fee pays. But nobody watching the account is a problem at any size. Weigh both. The fee against your margin. The cost of nobody watching against the fee.

Be honest about time. A rebuild in a competitive category takes eight to twelve months to break even. It takes about two years to compound. Anyone promising faster is selling something.

So we plan in years. 65% of our retained clients are past two years. Average tenure for retained clients is 32.7 months. On Redmond/Real Salt, the account grew 4.1x between 2022 and 2024. Its share of organic sales rose from 56% to 64% over the same years. Those figures are from our own case study. Organic share matters. Those are sales you didn't buy with ads.

Who full-service is not for:

  • You have someone in-house who owns listings, stock and account health. PPC-only may be enough.

  • You need break-even in weeks. We can't promise that. Nobody honest can.

  • You want to exit the brand. That's a sale, not an agency deal.

  • Your margin can't carry a fee yet. Fix the unit economics first.

We've sold on Amazon since 2012. We built and ran our own brands from zero to one. That's where our method comes from: audit, optimize, compound. Meet the operators behind it. We run a brand and category analysis first. If we're not the right fit, we'll say so on the first call.

Tell us where the channel stands today. We'll tell you what we would do, and whether we're the right people to do it!

Frequently asked questions

Are Amazon agencies worth it for small brands?

It depends on your margin more than your size. Amazon already takes a lot before any agency fee. Referral fees, fulfillment and storage fees, then advertising and promotions. One older industry analysis found Amazon's take had passed half of seller revenue.

Sellers feel it. In a survey this year, nearly half named fees as their biggest margin worry. 46% named advertising costs. Margins vary widely. In one survey of small sellers, 57% had margins above 10%. 13% were not yet profitable. If you're in that last group, a fee may not pay yet.

Ask any agency to show you the math before you sign. Ours is a flat retainer plus 3% of attributed sales, never a cut of ad spend. Even so, plan on eight to twelve months to break even in a competitive category. No agency pays for itself on day one.

How reliable are best Amazon agency ranking lists?

Treat them as marketing until they prove otherwise. Many are written by agencies that rank themselves first. Reports suggest many companies that lost search visibility in a recent Google update leaned on “best” lists ranking their own product No. 1. The practice isn't banned outright. It does clash with Google's guidance on reviews and trust.

Google Search Central's guidance on reviews says a “best” pick should explain why, with first-hand evidence. The FTC's fake-reviews rule goes further. It bars a business from passing off a site it controls as an independent reviewer of a category that includes its own products. And FTC guidance on endorsements notes that readers may not know “affiliate link” means the writer is paid. A bare label isn't enough.

Three checks for any list. Who wrote it? Do they sell the service? Do they say why, with evidence? This guide was written by an agency. We said so at the top.

What does Amazon Ads Verified Partner status mean for an agency?

It means Amazon assessed the agency against its qualification criteria for its ads partner program. It speaks to ads work. It is not a guarantee of results. It is not an Amazon endorsement. And it says nothing about listings, inventory or operations.

The criteria shift. In early 2024, one explainer said Verified required at least two team members with product certifications and recent campaign activity. That may have changed. One agency describes three tiers: Partner, Verified and Advanced. Accounts of the structure differ. One recent report also says new Verified and Advanced decisions were paused while Amazon finalizes a new structure. So a badge can lag the work. Check any agency's listing in Amazon's public partner directory.

Ours is based on data from the Amazon Ads Partner Network, not a form we filled out. It isn't a guarantee of results, and we won't sell it as one.

The Evolved Commerce Editorial Team

Content @ Evolved Commerce

This article was written by the Evolved Commerce team. Evolved Commerce manages founder-led brands on Amazon on a mostly-commission model, so it only profits when its clients do. The team writes about where the money actually goes on Amazon, and what it takes to build revenue that lasts.

OPERATORS, NOT AGENCIES

Article making sense?

If anything from what we wrote here resonates with you and what you are going through, let's chat.

Talk to an operator